Powys coalition policy questioned
Cllr Pete Lewington, who represents Newtown West, has criticised what he describes as “confusing and contradictory decisions” regarding the council’s net zero ambitions and its latest move to increase garden waste recycling fees.
In a letter to MyNewtown, he expressed doubts over the financial burden of the council’s pledge to reach net-zero carbon emissions by 2030, which he claims could cost residents over £400 million. While he acknowledged the importance of reducing carbon footprints, he warned that such policies must be “realistic, managed and cost-effective” in light of the financial pressures many households face.
“I was pleased to see that the portfolio holder agrees that this target should be reassessed as a priority matter,” Cllr Lewington wrote, suggesting that even within the administration, there are signs of reconsideration.
However, he took particular issue with the proposed rise in garden waste collection fees, arguing that it contradicts the council’s stated commitment to sustainability.
“If the council’s impact on the environment runs through all of its work as a ‘golden thread,’ then the latest proposal to increase the cost of garden waste recycling collections surely makes no sense. It hits people in their pockets and will do nothing to encourage recycling – if they are serious about the environment, they should look at reducing the cost!” he stated.
The council has defended the increase, maintaining that residents who do not wish to pay can still take their garden waste to one of Powys’ five recycling centres. However, Cllr Lewington pointed out that access to these facilities is also changing, with a new booking system being introduced. He fears this could create further obstacles for residents who want to recycle, particularly if they struggle with online booking or face long waits on the phone to secure a slot.
“We should be helping, not putting obstacles in the way of all of us who want to do our bit by recycling,” he argued.
A further concern he raised was the potential for unintended consequences, including an increase in illegal fly-tipping. “I really hope not, as I believe our residents are better than that, and they deserve better than this,” he said.
The council has yet to respond directly to Cllr Lewington’s criticisms, but previous statements have highlighted the financial pressures facing local authorities. Powys, like many councils across Wales and the UK, is grappling with budget constraints, and some argue that service charges, such as garden waste collection, are necessary to maintain broader waste and recycling initiatives.
Supporters of the net zero strategy argue that while the costs may seem high, the long-term environmental and economic benefits—such as energy efficiency and climate resilience—justify the investment. Additionally, they point out that waste collection schemes need to be financially sustainable, particularly if they are to continue supporting ambitious climate goals.
Critics, however, believe the council should reconsider how it balances affordability with environmental policy. Cllr Lewington’s comments reflect broader concerns about the practical impact of green initiatives on everyday residents, especially when the cost of living remains a major issue.
With the recycling fee changes set to come into effect, residents will soon experience first-hand how the new system works. Whether it will encourage more sustainable waste management or lead to increased frustration remains to be seen.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|